20. Bodybuilding to Boardrooms: Applying Discipline to Real Estate With Alexia Tuttle | Pressure Tested

In this episode of "Pressure Tested," host Kelly Roberts sits down with the multi-talented and highly-driven entrepreneur, Alexia Tuttle. Alexia shares her extraordinary journey from a chaotic, poverty-stricken childhood in Connecticut to becoming a successful partner in a decade-old worldwide nutrition coaching business, a commercial real estate investor, and co-founder of a new hydration brand. Alexia opens up about the core philosophies that drove her success: an intense focus on logic over emotion, which she adopted because emotional safety felt unsafe , and the discovery of discipline through competitive bodybuilding, which provided the structure she craved.

She details how she and her husband, a registered dietitian and pro bodybuilder , scaled their primary nutrition coaching business by 250% annually by prioritizing efficiency and a high work ethic , eventually moving to Dallas for greater personal and professional freedom. The conversation takes a deep dive into Alexia's pivot to commercial real estate. She candidly recounts a massive "Pressure Tested" failure: losing over $200,000 in collective earnest money by partnering with untrustworthy individuals on two initial multi-family deals in North Carolina and North Georgia. This painful lesson solidified her commitment to meticulous due diligence (underwriting 200+ deals before finding the right one) , local investing , and the importance of a transparent and honest gut check on partners.

Finally, Alexia and Kelly discuss the importance of radical transparency in business, arguing it is the "new currency," especially with investors. Alexia shares her unique approach to leadership, working with her partners, and managing investor relations by giving full disclosure—including the bad news—to build long-term trust and reputation over a single deal's profit. The episode concludes with a humorous look at her passion for bodybuilding, the pitfalls of the "all-or-nothing" mindset in fitness , and the unexpected creation of their third venture, a hydration brand. 00:00:00 - Transparency is the New Currency for Business